Tuesday, April 22, 2014

QPL Analysis of GAO report on IRS Performance



Quantified Perception analysis of GAO report on IRS
On April 21, the GAO released a briefing on their study on the IRS:
“Absorbing Budget Cuts Has Resulted in Significant Staffing Declines and Uneven Performance”

GAO analyzed the impacts of reduced budgets and employees on IRS since FY2009, concluding that there has been significant impact. The report is publicly available on the GAO website.

Quantified Perception has performed a Text Analysis Profile on the web announcement, the transmittal letter to Congress, and the briefing paper. Together, they constitute slightly over 5000 words (excluding appendices.)

Inasmuch as all three data sources reflect the same study and the summary conclusions from the study, QPL combined the three sources for analysis. The emphasis of GAO is on performance and services provided by IRS. It is noteworthy that “FTE” and FTEs” rank in the top five most frequently used words in the text, indicating the emphasis that GAO ascribes to the personnel reductions as a factor in lower performance of the IRS mission. Budget matters rank first in two-word phrases, followed by a miscellany of performance terms. Three-word phrases are centered on cause-and-effect concepts, notably including “international and offshore” as the single most used meaningful phrase. Four and five-word phrases similarly center on problem areas and IRS response to the challenges.

Quantified Perception believes that the GAO report carries enough charged language ot produce a shift to a higher priority on IRS funding in FY 2015 and beyond. With significance in the language to staffing and IT infrastructure issues, integrators should re-examine the IRS as a potential market for services and products to reverse the trend of the past five years.


Frequency of meaningful words and phrases in web announcement, transmittal letter, and briefing charts:
Most often used words
Occurrences
service
& services
56
operations
34
data
28
performance
26
fte & ftes
26
information
25
taxpayer
24
enforcement
20
support
18
trends
18
resources
17
cuts
16
budgetary
14
plan
14
taxpayers
14




Two-word Phrases
Occurrences
budget request,
budgetary resources,
& budget cuts
41
operations support
17
performance trends
11
information technology
9
average wait
8
priority programs
8
call volume
7




Three-word Phrases
Occurrences
other budgetary resources
14
full time equivalents
6
international and offshore
6
across the board
5
business systems modernization
5
improvement of services
5
information technology infrastructure
5
more strategically manage
5
offshore compliance issues
5
required by sequestration
5
rescission and reductions
5
services to taxpayers
5
staffing and performance
5
strategically manage operations
5
support for information
5
taxpayers refund fraud
5
theft and international
5




Four-word Phrases
Occurrences
across the board rescission
5
board rescission and reductions
5
by sequestration in fiscal
5
compliance issues the operating
5
congressional justifications for irs
5
enforcement to operations support
5
fraud and identity theft
5
from enforcement to operations
5
funding staffing and performance
5
identity theft and international
5
international and offshore compliance
5




Five-Word Phrases
Occurrences
board rescission and reductions required
5
for the improvement of services
5
from enforcement to operations support
5
funding staffing and performance trends
5
identity theft and international and
5
irs has proposed to transfer
5
operations support for information technology
5
sequestration in fiscal year 2014
5
support for information technology infrastructure
5
taxpayers refund fraud and identity
5


Thursday, April 17, 2014

NETWORX recompete has market implications



NS202 "Forbearance Interval" is a Game-Changer!

GSA has released the NS2020 Networks RFI, with a dozen pages of details on what they want for the next generation network-based and network-enabled services.


The stated purpose for the RFI is to inform industry, and provide a channel for industry to inform GSA, about the network strategy that will carry government for another decade and a half.

Quantified Perception has applied the Text Analysis Profiler(TAP), our proprietary analytics, to the RFI’s substantive statement to help make the RFI more accessible.

QPL’s Analysis
The NS2020 RFI is well structured and organized, relatively terse in presenting a broad subject area that certainly will engender a lot more text than the 20 pages of the released document. It is well-written, with a Microsoft-derived Flesch-Kincaid Reading level of 15.3. QPL gives it a 9.1 with our more rigorous Grade Level calculator.
With just under 3500 words after you drop the site table, there are a couple of interesting nuggets in the word and phrase frequency occurrences.

“Voice and data” are not surprisingly the most common substantive 3-word phrase, occurring nine times in the document. “The forbearance interval” occurs nine times, indicating that this concept for restricting awards will be a hard requirement to alter.

The RFI mandates that any domestic offeror must provide fixed price services in at least 50 of the designated CBSA’s (think “cities.”) During the Forbearance Interval (FI), contractors will be limited to bidding on projects by both geographic area and by the services required for a given task order. The RFI does a credible job in explain the concept, but it is likely to raise some discussion between GSA and potential offerors.

I predict that the Forbearance Interval will become a focal point in discussions and comments regarding NS2020. The parameters of the “FI” will have a huge impact on who can bid for specific task orders after award, with large companies in the drivers’ seats. We may see some interesting partnerships, alliances and even mergers of midsize network providers who are focused on the federal space, in order allow them to compete with the Majors.

Phase Analysis
There are several notable four- and five-word phrases repeated in the RFI, including mention of the “FI,” within longer word strings. “Voice and data services” is not surprising with nine mentions, but it is joined by “mandatory” three times and supplemented by “mandatory and optional services” an additional five times

“Mandatory and optional services” repetition reflects the importance of optional offerings to the forbearance interval. “Minimum set” and “minimum mandatory” are used five and six times each, again indicating the importance that the forbearance interval is likely to have on per-solicitation discourse.

“Comments and suggestions” are called for four times in the document, but are not explicitly requested around the forbearance interval, suggesting that there will be some resistance to modifying the language for that.

Other significant phrases include “geographic coverage, “infrastructure solutions”, and “domestic offerors.” Potential bidders should consider how these phrases will translate into requirements in the final RFP and make appropriate comments at this time – while GSA is still in “flexible” mode.



Five-word Phrases
Number of occurrences
ocabulary
Number of occurrences
structure and the forbearance interval
3

mandatory
20
mandatory voice and data services
3

information
20
how effective will the tiered
3

data
18
forbearance interval be in attracting
3

cbsas
16
for mandatory and optional services
3

coverage
16



minimum
16
Four-word Phrases


agencies
15
voice and data services
9

requirements
15
mandatory and optional services
5

geographic
14



service
13
Three-word Phrases


optional
12
mandatory and optional
5

strategy
11
tiered offeror structure
4

comments
10
comments and suggestions
4

forbearance
10



solutions
10
Two-word Phrases


infrastructure
9
optional services
12

network
9
geographic coverage
10

global
8
forbearance interval
9

suggestions
8
data services
9



infrastructure solutions
8



domestic offerors
7



minimum mandatory
6



minimum set
5